In 2022-2023, Bangkok's streets were flooded with Chinese EVs. BEV registrations exploded roughly eightfold, and headlines declared "Japan's automotive stronghold is crumbling." Then in 2024, BEV sales turned negative, while hybrid vehicle sales from Toyota and Honda surged nearly 50%. This isn't just a Thai story. From China to Europe, the same "reality check" is unfolding worldwide. What went wrong with the EV fever, and why is the world giving Japanese automakers a second look?

Thailand's EV Fever: From Explosive Growth to Sudden Cooldown

Between 2022 and 2023, Thailand's automotive market experienced what can only be described as "EV fever." The Thai government's "EV3.0" policy offered subsidies of up to 150,000 baht (approximately $4,300) per battery electric vehicle (BEV), and Chinese manufacturers rushed to enter the market. BEV registrations skyrocketed from roughly 1,900 units in 2021 to approximately 75,000 units in 2023.

Bangkok's boulevards filled with BYD Dolphins, MG4s, and Neta Vs. Media outlets worldwide hailed Thailand as the proving ground for Southeast Asia's electric future.

But the party didn't last.

According to data from Thailand's Department of Land Transport, BEV passenger car registrations fell 8.1% year-over-year in 2024 to approximately 70,000 units. Meanwhile, hybrid electric vehicle (HEV) sales surged 49.5% to about 127,000 units. In the very market that had been held up as a model for the EV transition, consumers were quietly voting with their wallets, and choosing hybrids.

The Resale Value Crisis: Why Thai Consumers Hit the Brakes

For the average Thai car buyer, the single most important factor in purchasing a vehicle is resale value. A car isn't just transportation, it's an asset that can be sold when times get tough.

And on this front, BEVs have been a bitter disappointment. Research from Krungsri Research shows that 2021-model BEVs in Thailand had depreciated an average of approximately 18% from their original list price by 2024. The pace of technological advancement means that a BEV purchased just a few years ago can feel outdated compared to newer models with longer range and better features.

Making matters worse, Chinese manufacturers launched aggressive price wars. At Thailand's 2024 Motor Expo, the BYD Seal saw a price cut of roughly 19%, and the Neta VII dropped about 21%. When new car prices keep falling, used car values plummet further. This vicious cycle has eroded consumer confidence.

According to an Ipsos Thailand survey, 42% of consumers considering an EV cited resale value concerns as a barrier to purchase, alongside inadequate charging infrastructure (50%) and safety concerns (54%).

The Charging Infrastructure Gap: Bangkok vs. the Countryside

Another major obstacle for BEV adoption in Thailand is the uneven development of charging infrastructure. While central Bangkok has seen a reasonable buildout of charging stations, the vast rural areas that make up much of the country remain severely underserved. For residents in provincial towns and farming communities who rely on long-distance driving, BEVs simply aren't practical.

The Thai government had targeted making 30% of domestic vehicle production electric by 2030. But faced with the mid-2024 sales slowdown, it was forced to course-correct. In July 2024, the government introduced excise tax incentives for hybrid vehicles and reduced taxes on plug-in hybrids (PHEVs) and mild hybrids (MHEVs). The policy message was clear: rather than betting everything on BEVs, Thailand needed a flexible approach aligned with global market realities.

China's Market Tells the Same Story

What's happening in Thailand isn't an isolated phenomenon. The world's largest EV market, China, is experiencing a remarkably similar trend.

Data from the International Energy Agency (IEA) shows that BEVs' share of China's new energy vehicle (NEV) sales fell from 80% in 2020 to below 60% in 2024. The gap has been filled by PHEVs, whose share grew to approximately 30%, and extended-range EVs (EREVs), which now account for over 10%.

In the first nine months of 2025, China's PHEV market grew 21% year-over-year to approximately 3.86 million units, but this was a sharp deceleration from the 35.7% growth rate in the first half. Meanwhile, BEV growth actually accelerated to 37.4% over the same period, suggesting the market is recalibrating rather than collapsing.

Even BYD, the undisputed king of China's EV market, felt the shift. The company's PHEV sales declined year-over-year for six consecutive months in mid-2025, while its BEV sales grew 36.8%. The era of "everything electric sells" is giving way to a more nuanced market where consumers demand practical solutions.

Chinese consumers, like their Thai counterparts, are increasingly prioritizing practicality. BEVs dominate in cities with robust charging networks, but in suburban and rural areas, PHEVs and EREVs offer the comfort of being able to run on gasoline when charging isn't available.

Europe: When Subsidies Disappear, So Do Sales

Europe's EV landscape has also undergone significant upheaval.

Germany abruptly terminated its EV purchase subsidies at the end of 2023, and the result was immediate: BEV registrations dropped 18.2% in 2024. The shock was severe enough that Germany announced a new €3 billion ($3.3 billion) EV incentive program starting in 2026, though this time with income-based tiers and a maximum subsidy of €6,000 ($6,600) per vehicle, well below previous levels.

France slashed its EV subsidy budget from €1.5 billion to €1 billion for 2025, reducing the maximum per-vehicle bonus from €7,000 to €4,000. The country is also tightening environmental scoring for subsidy eligibility, effectively penalizing vehicles with higher manufacturing carbon footprints.

Perhaps most significantly, the EU is moving to require that electric vehicles be at least 70% manufactured within Europe to qualify for government subsidies, starting with the Net Zero Industry Act provisions that took effect in January 2026. This effectively locks most Chinese-made EVs out of Europe's subsidy ecosystem.

The lesson is stark: EV adoption models built on subsidies are inherently fragile. When the money stops, so does demand. This structural vulnerability reveals that BEVs have not yet achieved true cost competitiveness with conventional vehicles in most markets.

Toyota and Honda's "Multi-Pathway Strategy" Gets a Second Look

Against this backdrop of global recalibration, a strategy that was once dismissed as "too cautious" is gaining new respect: the multi-pathway approach championed by Toyota and Honda.

Rather than going all-in on BEVs, this strategy involves offering a full spectrum of powertrains, HEVs, PHEVs, BEVs, fuel cell vehicles (FCEVs), and even hydrogen combustion engines, tailored to the needs and infrastructure of each regional market.

Toyota President Koji Sato reaffirmed this commitment at the company's May 2025 earnings briefing, stating that "the path and pace of electrification diffusion differ considerably depending on the type of fuel or energy." It's an approach rooted in a distinctly Japanese philosophy: rather than imposing a single solution on diverse markets, listen to what customers actually need.

In Thailand, Toyota maintained its position as the market leader with a 38.5% share in 2024. The company added a hybrid version of its popular Yaris Ativ sedan and began local BEV production in 2025, demonstrating a "both/and" rather than "either/or" approach.

Honda has similarly strengthened its hybrid lineup across Asian markets, while accelerating EV development for markets like China where demand warrants it. The keyword is flexibility.

EV Adoption Rates: A Global Snapshot

A comparison of BEV market shares across regions reveals just how uneven the electric transition remains.

Norway stands as the global outlier, with approximately 88% of new car sales being BEVs. China's NEV penetration has reached roughly 50%, but about 40% of that comes from PHEVs and EREVs, pure BEV share is closer to 30%. Europe-wide BEV sales share has stagnated at around 20%. Thailand hit a monthly peak of roughly 25% BEV share in June 2025, though annual figures are more volatile. And Japan remains at just approximately 1.7%.

These numbers tell a clear story: the world is nowhere near a "BEV-only" future. The optimal solution varies dramatically based on each region's energy mix, infrastructure maturity, consumer income levels, and used car market dynamics.

Lessons from the EV Fever: The Gap Between Idealism and Reality

Thailand's experience offers a concentrated lesson in the gap between EV idealism and market reality.

Subsidies can create demand, but when they disappear, so does the demand. Continuous price cuts on new vehicles destroy used car values and erode consumer trust. Pushing sales without building charging infrastructure accumulates owner frustration. And depending on financially fragile startup brands creates after-sales service vacuums. Consider Neta: the Chinese EV maker saw its Thai market share collapse from 12% to 4% in just two years, closing 20 of its 60 showrooms.

Hybrids, by contrast, don't require charging infrastructure, can refuel at any gas station, and maintain relatively stable resale values. For consumers who prioritize "reality" over "ideals," hybrid vehicles represent an eminently rational choice.

So, What Does Japan Think? And What About Your Country?

In Japan, Toyota and Honda's multi-pathway strategy has drawn both criticism, "too cautious," "falling behind in the EV race", and vindication as EV booms cool around the world. The consensus is increasingly shifting toward the view that Japanese automakers' measured approach may have been right all along.

EVs are undeniably a crucial pillar of future mobility. But their adoption requires a gradual, region-specific approach that accounts for local realities, infrastructure, economics, and consumer psychology. Thailand's story illustrates this vividly.

How far along is the EV transition in your country? Are hybrids part of the picture? Is charging infrastructure adequate? We'd love to hear about the situation where you live.

References